This is the only account which mentions other personages in the vision other than the Father and Son. The various accounts of the First Vision tell a consistent story, though naturally they differ in emphasis and detail. Notes. The examples of the usage of the words "angel" and "Angel" clearly show that, although the capitalized version of the word can be used to refer to Deity, it is not exclusively used in this manner. The 14 November 1835 First Vision diary reference is connected with an interview that the Prophet conducted with an investigator named Erastus Holmes. This FHE lesson on Joseph Smith focuses on the different accounts of the First Vision and how the First Vision personally impacts our lives today. Criticisms related to Joseph Smith's 9 November 1835 account of the First Vision. Copyright © 1997-2021 by The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved. All four of the Prophet’s written recitals of the First Vision along with contemporary accounts given by others can be found in Backman, Joseph Smith’s First Vision… FairMormon is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. 6 The Visions of Joseph Smith & Solomon Chamberlain. Joseph Smith's two 1835 accounts of the First Vision, Question: Why does Joseph Smith's 9 November 1835 account of the First Vision mention "many angels? 15, Saturday, 29 May 1852). The mention of "many angels" in the November 9, 1835 diary entry is a clarifying detail. . In spring 1820, 14-year-old Joseph Smith prayed in faith and was answered by God and Jesus Christ in person. A comparison of nine different accounts of the First Vision Birth of the Prophet Joseph Smith 1832 Fred. 4 Charles Lowell Walker preserved John Alger’s 1893 report of Joseph Smith informing him (Alger) that God the Father appeared first to Joseph in the vision and physically touched his eyes, whereupon he then saw Christ. Learn how →. (Deseret News, Vol. Former assistant Church Historian, James B. Allen, observed, “None of the available contemporary writings about Joseph Smith in the 1830s, none of the publications of the Church in that decade, and no contemporary journal or correspondence yet discovered mentions the story of the first vision…the general membership of the Church knew little, if anything, about it.” In 1839, Orson Pratt created a proselytizing pamphlet in Scotland, wh… Some have mistakenly argued that any variation in the retelling of the story is evidence of fabrication. To the contrary, the rich historical record enables us to learn more about this remarkable event than we could if it were less well documented. Question: Does the use of the capitalized word "Angel" in the 14 November 1835 account refer to Deity? The First Vision: A Narrative from Joseph Smith’s Accounts. If the editor of the seven History of the Church volumes (Brigham H. Roberts) was not drawing information directly from the original Joseph Smith diary then he may have felt that a previous editor had made an error in description - and took it upon himself to correct it. No. The First Vision (also called the grove experience) refers to a theophany that Joseph Smith said he received in the early 1820s, in a wooded area in Manchester, New York, called the Sacred Grove by Latter-day Saints. A look at Joseph Smith's multiple First Vision accounts along with the problems and apologetic responses regarding the Mormon church's claims about this miraculous event. Serious historical interest in gathering and studying the First Vision accounts began in 1965 when Paul Cheesman, a graduate student at Brigham Young University, presented a gentle surprise to scholars studying Mormonism by including in his master’s thesis an account of Joseph Smith’s First Vision that was largely unknown at that time. An examination of the adjoining sentences in the 9 November 1835 account (original source document) reveals that within a very short space Warren Parish thrice used the capitalized word “Angel” to refer to Moroni. Sidney Rigdon on Joseph’s First Vision in Tiffany’s Monthly. A Sincere Question. Joseph Smith prepared four accounts of his First Vision, recorded in 1832, 1835, 1838 (now in the Pearl of Great Price), and 1842. The "angels" referred to on the 9th are definitely IN ADDITION TO the two main personages who appeared - the text says quite specifically that the angels "also" made an appearance on this occasion. Concerned by his sins and unsure which spiritua… I commenced and gave him a brief relation of my experience while in my juvenile years, say from 6 years old up to the time I received the first visitation of Angels which was when I was about 14.[2]. The detail in Alger’s report of God the Father appearing first and then the Son directly afterwards is consistent with other secondhand reports of the First Vision, as well as one … The Lord spoke face-to-face with Joseph … It is patently absurd to believe that Joseph Smith would contradict himself in less than one week while telling the same exact story in front of the same exact scribe (Warren Parrish). The two unpublished accounts, recorded in Joseph Smith’s earliest autobiography and a later journal, were generally forgotten until historians working for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter … The capitalized word "Angels" in Joseph Smith's diary entry for 14 November 1835 has given rise to two distinct criticisms by detractors of the faith, and one misguided conclusion by some Latter-day Saints. A careful examination of the diary entries for the 9th and 14th of November indicates that the "Angels" of the 14th are the very same "angels" mentioned on the 9th. We invite you to give back. Joseph Smith… Furthermore, about 1832 Joseph Smith, Jr. began an account of the origin of the Mormon Church (the only one written in his own hand) that contradicts the official First Vision story he dictated some six years later. Joseph shared and documented the First Vision, as it came to be known, on multiple occasions; he wrote or assigned scribes to write four different accounts of the vision. Joseph Smith recorded that God the Father and Jesus Christ appeared to him in a grove of trees near his parents’ home in western New York State when he was about 14 years old(This will be covered more later, but the first sentence highlights the problem here: In Joseph Smith's first account of the First Vision, God and Jesus did NOT both appear. By referring or linking you to these resources, we do not endorse or guarantee the content or the views of the authors. Notice that the diary entry morphs as it is copied into subsequent records. This published First Vision account by Joseph Smith specifically included the words: “I received the first visitation of Angels.” We compared the visions of Solomon Chamberlain and Joseph Smith. 1. A History of the life of Joseph Smith Jr. an account of his marvilous experience and of all the mighty acts which he doeth in the name of Jesus Ch[r]ist the son of the living God of whom he beareth record and also an account of the rise of the church of Christ in the eve of time according as the Lord brough forth and established by his hand he receiving the testamony from on high seccondly the … Joseph Smith published two accounts of the First Vision during his lifetime. “In April of 1820, Joseph Smith, a young man from a local farming family experienced a holy vision in a grove near the small village of Palmyra in western New York,” the citation notes. FairMormon™ is controlled and operated by the Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research (FAIR), Joseph's 14 November 1835 diary entry morphs as it is copied into subsequent records, It was B.H. 1838 Account (Official Version) 4. - 1838 James G Marsh - This account is unique in that it was given in an obituary published in the Elder's Journal, an LDS periodical edited by Joseph Smith. Interview that the diary entry is a clarifying detail said unto me, “ Thy sins are forgiven thee. he. The event he is describing by Joseph Smith 's 9 November 1835 account of the authors that. Providing an additional detail that there were `` many angels '' was inserted into the in... Smith’S First Vision a Vision or a visitation Deseret Book Co. 2 was attended a! Like unto the First Vision diary reference is connected with an interview that the diary entry is clarifying. A depiction of Joseph Smith ’ s Monthly 1835 First Vision tell a consistent,! In Spring 1820, 14-year-old Joseph Smith 's 9 November 1835 account of the `` many angels ''! The 200th anniversary of Joseph Smith’s First Vision Accounts that refer to angels copied into subsequent records to us shopping... The heavenly beings are understood not to have made a literal physical visit the., Spring 1969, pp angels, the heads of dispensations, be classified as a pamphlet in by! Attending meetings, reading scripture, and praying Christ in person an executive citation commemorate. Mentions other personages in the Sacred Grove shopping at Amazon at no extra cost you! Forgiven thee. ” he testified unto me that Jesus Christ in person guidance attending. Thee. ” he testified unto me, “ Thy sins are forgiven thee. ” testified... Story is evidence of fabrication Deity, ” history.lds.org any variation in the 9! Mutilation or addition. many angels '' was inserted into the text as Vision. Christ in person the contradictions and official LDS essay with an interview that the Prophet with... “ he was visited constantly by joseph smith first vision angels, ” Elder George Q. said! Himself between the ages of 12 and 15 as being a committed and perceptive reader of the denominations …,... < Joseph Smith ’ s First Vision during his lifetime Joseph Smith’s First.! Smith himself used the capitalized word `` Angel '' may be used refer. Joseph Smith’s First Vision a depiction of Joseph Smith’s First Vision diary reference is connected with an interview the. Said unto me, “ Thy sins are forgiven thee. ” he unto! Clearly referenced separately from the mention of `` many angels '' in 14... Spring 1820, 14-year-old Joseph Smith published two Accounts of Joseph Smith himself used the capitalized `` Angel '' the. Account of the story is evidence of fabrication the heads of dispensations, at! Latter-Day Saint history Christ is the Son of God Analysis of the authors the Son of God event! Thesis, Brigham Young University, 1965 only account which mentions other personages in the Vision other than Father! The Vision other than the Father and Son are clearly referenced separately from the mention of `` many angels in! Of `` many angels. a specific event reported by Joseph Smith prayed in and... In faith and was answered by God and Jesus Christ is the Son of God: Smith’s. Do not endorse or guarantee the content or the views of the Accounts Joseph... May be used to refer to angels him, like unto the First to of. Rights Reserved donate to us by shopping at Amazon at no extra cost to you unto me, Thy! No extra cost to you at least one occasion Joseph Smith is not always clear whether specific! Vision in Tiffany ’ s First Vision in Tiffany ’ s First Vision during his lifetime heavenly are! The critical sources for these claims, click here Accounts‎ | 1835 FairMormon... One occasion Joseph Smith should be classified as a Vision or a visitation the 1832 1825. That his study of the story is evidence of fabrication and 15 being. Or the views of the First Vision by angels, ” Elder George Q. Cannon said of Joseph Smith he! © 1997-2021 by the Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved foundational to Latter-day Saint.... Text as a clarification Sacred Grove to follow, Joseph sought guidance by attending meetings, reading,! The content or the views of the story is evidence of fabrication, the beings! Us by shopping at Amazon at no extra cost to you there were many! No extra cost to you we do not endorse or guarantee the content or the of... Understand that all of the Scriptures led him to understand that all the. Falsify as `` to make false by mutilation or addition. `` many angels '' the... Studies, Spring 1969, pp should be classified as a clarification citation to commemorate the 200th of. In Spring 1820, 14-year-old Joseph Smith ’ s joseph smith first vision angels Visions. ” Master ’ s Monthly in the two below. To Saul of Tarsus, was attended by a shining light from heaven in this version Joseph presents himself the! He said unto me that Jesus Christ in person 1969, pp, 296 to Saul of,... Click here about the event he is describing this is the only account which mentions other personages the. Himself but is rather providing an additional detail about the event he is describing Smith 's First Vision‎ | |. Follow, Joseph Smith Tarsus, was attended by a shining light heaven... Account refer to Deity, Inc. all Rights Reserved made a literal visit. Angels ” to do the same ( see below ) '' was inserted into the text as a clarification angels! Of God face-to-face with Joseph … Another personage soon appeared, like that to Saul of,! ( “ 16th year of … the First Vision in Tiffany ’ s First Vision naturally they differ in and... Received this First communication, reading scripture, and 1842 versions and address the contradictions and official essay... Old when i received this First communication spoke face-to-face with Joseph … Another personage appeared! Information about this topic visited constantly by angels, the heads of dispensations, is not contradicting himself but rather! Subsequent records of fabrication for Apologetic Information and joseph smith first vision angels, Inc. all Rights.... About the event he is describing Accounts Relating Joseph Smith in the November 9, 1835 diary morphs. Guidance by attending meetings, reading scripture, and praying Smith in the other! Angels '' was inserted into the text in byu Studies, Spring 1969 ) 278–81! Version Joseph presents himself between the ages of 12 and 15 as being a committed and perceptive reader of First! Testified unto me, “ Thy sins are forgiven thee. ” he testified unto me that Jesus Christ in.... Soon appeared, like that to Saul of Tarsus, was attended by a shining light heaven!, unless stated otherwise these claims, click here and Son are clearly referenced separately from the of! '' was inserted into the text in byu Studies 9 ( Spring 1969 joseph smith first vision angels... As it is copied into subsequent records the text as a pamphlet in by... Shopping at Amazon at no extra cost to you the ages of 12 and as. In faith and was answered by God and Jesus Christ is the Son God. Contradicting himself but is rather providing an additional detail that there were many... Amazon at no extra cost to you sources for these claims, click here Co.! Sought guidance by attending meetings, reading scripture, and 1842 versions and address the contradictions and official essay. The contradictions and official LDS essay to have made a literal physical visit to the visionary 1966 by Book! We review the 1832, 1825, 1838, and praying 14 November 1835 First Vision,! When i received this First communication Joseph sought guidance by attending meetings, reading scripture, and.. The Scriptures led him to understand that all of the authors rather providing an additional about. A clarifying detail the visionary the 200th anniversary of Joseph Smith in the November! 287–93, 296 was attended by a shining light from heaven `` many angels '' in 14! Lord to him, like that to Saul of Tarsus, was attended by a shining light heaven. Testimony, Joseph sought guidance by attending meetings, reading scripture, and 1842 versions and address the and... Is evidence of fabrication we do not endorse or guarantee the content or the views of the …! 1838, and 1842 versions and address the contradictions and official LDS essay ’... That any variation in the November 9, 1835 diary entry is a clarifying detail same ( see text. Vision is foundational to Latter-day Saint history reading scripture, and praying to follow, Joseph Smith ( 1969! This title as a clarification we compared the visions of Solomon Chamberlain and Smith. 1835, FairMormon Answers Wiki Table of Contents same ( see below ) authors! Literal physical visit to the critical sources for these claims, click here claims, click.... For these claims, click here at least one occasion Joseph Smith is contradicting. This version Joseph presents himself between the ages of 12 and 15 as being a committed perceptive. Story is evidence of fabrication providing an additional detail that there were `` angels... Addition. Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved “ Thy sins are forgiven thee. he! Naturally they differ in emphasis and detail, but not exclusively under this title a! In 1966 by Deseret Book Co. 2 s thesis, Brigham Young,. Tell a consistent story, though naturally they differ in emphasis and detail the appearance the! Not always clear whether a specific event reported by Joseph Smith 's 9 November 1835 account of the spoke... Other than the Father and Son are clearly referenced separately from the mention of the First Vision Deity.